American Millennium Insurance Company (AMIC) strives to provide exceptional and responsive claims service to all parties involved in an accident.  From first notice of loss through claim resolution, you can count on the AMIC team to complete a thorough investigation, fairly resolve verified claims and rigorously defend our Insureds’ interests. 

AMIC provides these convenient ways to report a new claim:

  1. Email your loss details, police report and contact information to
  2. Complete our Claims Reporting Form
  3. Call 973-628-6060 x 251
  4. Fax 973-628-6070

AMIC’s in-house staff handles all claims for direct written business and some of our program business. Call x 251 to determine who your adjuster is or contact our staff below:

Claims Reporting and Support
Supervisor: Lisa Dickersonlisa.dickerson@citadelrisk.comx217
Olympia (Lynn) LaParaolympia.lapara@citadelrisk.comx215
Stephanie Almontestephanie.almonte@citadelrisk.comx221
Property Damage:
Supervisor: Tamica Barbertamica.barber@citadelrisk.comx219
Sean Callahansean.callahan@citadelrisk.comx302
Jillian Fermaintjillian.fermaint@citadelrisk.comx209
Dianne Taylordianne.taylor@citadelrisk.comx220
Angie Mammonangie.mammon@citadelrisk.comx214
Nanette Pavonananette.pavona@citadelrisk.comx222
Bodily Injury and Litigation:
Vicky Sticklevicky.stickle@citadelrisk.comx210
Theresa Rotatheresa.rota@citadelrisk.comx212
Jill Collettjill.collett@citadelrisk.comx202
Michael Alexandrowiczmichael.alexandrowicz@citadelrisk.comx218
VP of Claims:
Howard Brysonhoward.bryson@citadelrisk.comx207
AVP of Claims:
John Tripicchiojohn.tripicchio@citadelrisk.comx203
Senior Claims Examiners:
Midge Beierwaltesmidge.beierwaltes@citadelrisk.comx324
Miriam DuBoismiriam.dubois@citadelrisk.comx205
Matt Menkowskimatthew.menkowski@citadelrisk.comx216
Dan Whalendan.whalen@citadelrisk.comx208